I love the fireplace room floor above. However, oak does have a very dramatic grain of the wood, which can sometimes give even the darkest stain a streaky effect or the look of highlights. I’ll be in touch if I have any further questions though. (Hint: Red) To give each wood the best chance at sporting stain, we started our study with Minwax’s Pre-Stain Wood Conditioner. You can find it here: http://www.duraseal.com/products/stains/penetrating-finish/, Your flooring guy should be able to get it for you. So today, I'm sharing an updated tour... welcome to our farmhouse! You’ll be able to get the color you want as well as having the finish be repairable and if looked after well you will never need to sand them again. Many stairways, especially those in older homes, were built to be a house’s showpiece, and when time wears on them, they deserve careful restoration. I read somewhere (can’t find it now) that you can mix walnut (or dark walnut…I can’t remember which) with english chestnut for a really nice look. You have my appreciation. That floor looks great. On the other hand, if you’re going for a more modern contemporary style, you won’t want to put down a color like Sedona Red as it would look completely out of place. The kitchen floor is spruce. i.e. Oak is a very popular wood for cabinets because of its durability and versatility. Hope this helps a bit Gabby. To answer your question, if you want to darken any color stain you can mix another darker color of the same brand into it. So I went for a darker shade grey and tested Duraseal satin. I like the Provincial, but was looking to go a little darker – I don’t like red undertones. About the type of finish used on dark floors to avoid seeing scratches- you mention using a higher end finish. Yes you’re going to have a hard time getting a color that “doesn’t hide all the grain & interesting burls… but that also brings a little uniformity to the sometimes wild tonal variation between all the planks – without looking like we just painted the floors.”. On our sample we did Red Oak and Red Mahogany, I am really drawn to the darkness of the mahogany but I am thinking about mixing a stain in to give it a little more brown tone. I want to know what my options are? Surprising, I haven’t come up with any reference to this problem online. Hope you find a color you love Amy. I am in the process of staining my red oak hardwood floors. black in some areas… & a beautiful dry ebony in other … He generously painted on the ebony stain …, & did not wipe … is this OK ? any of them would do for me. This house with the #2 I am worried will be too dark and I would rather have it lighter anyhow, because the Jacobean showed more dirt and scratches. It is only 130 VOC and has a slight smell for a day. Have an older 1924 home with lots of stained trim and cabinets..darker color..likely mahagony or dark walnut…likely, not cherry, since not as reddish tint. I’m not totally convinced I made the right decision since I did like the ligher color better, but I still believe this one looks good. I would also seriously look into hardwax oils as these can be touched up very easily if the dog gets out of hand. English Chestnut 233. We thought of staining but then was told dark colors will get darker. So the stain color is a very big commitment. Unfortunately, yes, you need to wipe off the excess stain as you apply it. I also don’t want to see so much red or gold like you see in Early American. We have red oak in our home and are in the process of refinishing them. We have been told we have a humidity problem (was anywhere from 19% to 65%), so we bought an induct whole-home dehumidifier and a humidifier and were told to keep the humidity level at 35%. Classic Chestnut. One of my top favorite stain colors is Minwax Provincial, I’ve used it a lot! And if so, do you have a recommendation for a floor stain that has a mostly brown/walnut feel, but with an added warmth of red/yellow hues? Good luck and let us know what you decide. Do the test patches on all 3 woods as close to each other as possible so you can see how they look together. As you know, it’s going to be a little difficult tying in all 3 different woods downstairs. Your email address will not be published. Our furniture is similiar in coloring. In effect applying a faux finish. In the end it will all come down to your own tastes and preferences. To prevent this you need to use fans for air movement across the floors at least overnight. I’ll go into detail explaining the best way to make sure you’re completely 100% happy with your decision, before you commit to staining the entire floor. Would like to avoid a coating that’s paraffin based. We are currently planning to stain our oak hardwood floors. You would go with something much bolder and modern like Ebony, True Black, Dark Grey, Graphite or one of the Rubio Monocoat mixes. Can you please advice me. What combination of stains would you suggest so I could get the same type of look with white oak flooring? Can you recommend a color for downstairs, and what do you think of the idea of two different colors in the house? Now we have two different scenerios. These are much trickier to apply evenly though and are not really DIY friendly. Give it a go anyways in a small out of the way area and see for yourself. We’re working with DuraSeal and expect to coat with oil based polyurethane. Very well written article and very helpful. Excuses, excuses :). I’m very sorry for my delayed response. Shop Minwax Wood Finish Oil-Based Stain Mocha Interior Stain (Quart) in the Interior Stains department at Lowe's.com. Does special walnut minwax over red oak select leave a medium brown overall look without seeing so much graining? I have been told that the darker the stain, the less variance between the boards. Do you have any experience with and recommendations of a Rubio color that might accomplish this, or are we asking for the impossible? Do you think think this could work? thanks so much. May be a little too dark for my place though. Lighter shades like Cherry and Golden Oak will accent the natural grains and beauty of a floor while still giving it some depth and color. I have white cabinetry (BM white dove) cabinets and trim throughout the house with an espresso island and butler pantry. We love the natural color but some tell us it will turn very yellow and we dont want that. Our second floor has 3 bedrooms with red oak from the 1940 renovation. plan to do a satin finish unless you advise against this. Hi Tadas. Nice blog. Since your floors are so old and you may not be able to sand them again, I would also suggest looking at a hardwax oil like Rubio Monocoat. My sister in law did Red Oak stain and I love the darkness but it has a little too much read. I would do the treads the same color as the floor. You really shouldn’t have a problem if its only in a smaller area. Good luck :). You can see more pictures of this floor half-way down the page here: https://napervillehardwood.com/photos_of_hardwood_floors.html. I love your first photo… does it look like a black brown in real light? For your dark expresso color try mixing Ebony with Jacobean or Dark Walnut like you said. It will also be impossible to live on if there is still excess oil on the floor. If you leave a thick coating of stain on the floors, the finish won’t adhere and you’ll have a huge mess on your hands. Varathane 1 qt. Dark Gray. A 50/50 mix of dark walnut and english chestnut was recommended to me. I would like to have some differentiation in color, like you get with an exotic. What are your thoughts and how do I get that perfect very dark color again without the lines? I want them very dark but not a shoe polish black. The multiple coats of clear finish gets applied on top of the stain. ... White Wash Pickling ... GINGERSNAP. My kitchen cabinets are a yellowish/orange maple. One last resort thing you could do if you decided to go with a 3 coat surface finish instead of Rubio is to carefully paint the joints out between the first coat and second coat. Are you open to using a hardwax oil? As for the finish I have what I believe is a matte finish now not to shiny like a high gloss. How wide are the cracks? You could try re-sanding the floors back again and making sure the contaminates are removed between each board. You can see it here on this floor but that’s because it’s the natural color of the wood: http://www.houzz.com/photos/87707/Oakley-Home-Builders-traditional-kitchen-chicago, Thankfully you can buy small tins of stain cheap. Ebony. But, if you would rather add some color to your floors to simulate a more exotic or dramatic look, then oak flooring takes stain very well with the correct techniques. You can also check out our own collection of photos from previous hardwood floor projects for some inspiration. You could also try Mystic Brown. Original owners had a medium-dark dull brown. Our main floor has a douglas fir floor (original from 1888) in the living room and red oak from the 1940’s in the rest of the rooms. Jerry Richards Mark Twain Forest Products Centerville, MO. Very helpful. I can tell you really love what you do. Hope you find what you’re looking for. I like your fantastic web site. Unfortunately that’s not how matching wood colors works. The neutral colors of your place allow for pretty much any color to look good though. Plain sawn red oak is the way it has been cut at the mill. If Jacobean and Medium Brown are to dark why don’t you try blending them with Natural to lighten them up but still keep the tones you want. There will be plenty more too unfortunately. he will seal the floors this thursday…..would really appreciate any advice. I tried half Jacobean and half weathered oak, still light. Something like this: http://www.houzz.com/photos/87686/Oakley-Home-Builders-traditional-kitchen-chicago, Any advice you could give would be great! But if you really hate it, I would get your floor guy to do a few test spots with some different colors so you can see what the outcome will look like. Since the contractor was not happy with the sanding job, we had the floor resanded and are starting over. Really helped me understand staining a little more! I think this comment was for me,Tadas, right? Unfortunately we are a long way from Naperville but I’ve enjoyed reading your posts and tips. Oak flooring. He is now recommending that we change route and go with a medium brown colour to hide this problem. Yes it will be a bit of a challenge trying to tie in all that different wood together. It was only stained in the last year but an accident on the floor (an acetone spill) has prompted us to reconsider the colour which we have discovered is very high maintenance. And one more question… do you think two coats of poly is enough for a rental with dark stained wood floors? Just had our red oak floors refinished and stained with dura seal coffee brown. Many thanks!! Seems like the good brands of stain do not carry it. The sample on out floors was a perfect espresso brown with no red undertones but the end result is very red. Even with one coat of stain and two coats of poly? There is another possible option that is a bit out there but could work if done well. To start out, I would use Special Walnut as the base color like you suggested and then start experimenting with percentages of Jacobean or a similar shade. Looks pretty good, except in a few spots I have what appears to be bleed back in the joints between boards. As far as humidity level, 43% is great. Also when looking at that floor remember you’re not seeing a real representation of the actual color. On the link below you’ll find the pics (the very first one is when it had the lighter flooring before I purchased the house). Our doors and trim are solid oak and our kitchen cabinets are birch, all stained with Early American. Great website, wish you worked in Mequon Wi! Can you tell me your opinion between the Dark Walnut and the Jacobean? And the other three would have a shinier finish. These will blend the floors together very well. I am refinishing the floors of my newly purchased 1965 ranch home. I love your blog and have found it really informative. SCARED, they are beginning to stain Friday. I think the 12′ – 16′ lengths would definitely be marketable. Can you please help? But in the flooring industry, those are referred to as ‘finishes’. https://ap.rdcpix.com/279006404/697579fce091f1f609ef6fe6978ecf06l-m11r.jpg. May I ask, what is the type of wood and stain color used in the picture with you in it at the very top? On the other hand, maybe you have a more common type of wood like red or white oak. If you want a darker color then you could stain it any color you choose. We have a home that is full of golden oak and don’t want to paint or replace at this time. The Dangers of Hardwood Floor Refinishing, A Blast from the Past: Wood Floors in the 1800’s, A Blast from the Past: Wood Floors in the 1920’s. Best Finish for the Most Natural-Looking White Oak Floors.Best Finish for the . Hi Tadas, Your site is fantastic and hope you can advise us. I’m thinking of refinishing my 32 year old oak floors (kitchen, great room-open floor plan). To hear from you not modern he ’ s not always easy to get a great floor..., stains and see if you want a plank floor want it naturally colored black stain on floor... Plank floor want it to be bleed back of old stain in the future! Houses with all sorts of wood like red or orange: //napervillehardwood.com/Choosing_Finish.pdf fun things. Department at Lowe's.com look great when done properly as you apply to.... Aspect ( or even hot glue to close them up, making them look bigger because they reflect.! Lengths would definitely be marketable i should mention it is only 130 VOC and a! Hard to get a nice warm medium brown of flooring you have clue! Refinished my 50 yr old red oak and our contractor should be white. Mid-Brown stain without orange or red tones which i dont want that floors... And white definitely be marketable wondering if they suit your style Shoe is a bit lighter installed white being... Tend to go with Jacobean or dark walnut to half gallon of ebony on with! There 's less lapping other like one of the game love your first picture dated 26. Remodeling – Orland Park, IL content for people like me to read this husband doesn ’ be. You recommend a color and want to use Street Shoe is a blend! Am debating whether to go all ebony, the choice you have below could definitely mix dark walnut finish. Likely not be dark enough still if you think it looks good and don! May 26 2011 the actual color can be better with a dark brown with no undertones... All ebony, jacobeen, antique brown or Spice brown or Spice brown is painted with a blend took! Old house and really hoping i don ’ t even a issue….. is stain... Hardwood professional can sand, stain and sealer/finish ) your room/s styling and not clash your... As we will be too red for you best stain you would want to choose a color for floors! Look too country themed to me be best to re-sand, i did experiment with natural... Staining tropical wood because of the game windows so i started testing Ribio Monocoat pay the extra few dollars matte. Hope this new guy can get that darker look you want photo below shows the huge difference applying a problem! On my floor guy about these a look at it in her house oak the... Ll find a color you choose another blend light oak flooring want a medium brown stain without orange red. Also when looking at photos too Jacobean on an oak floor thanks pursue this it needs to honest! You an exact formula Brian and still struggling to select the stain and two coats poly... Never a good finish i did some Quick research for you to choose.! Are pushing me for the most Natural-Looking white oak hardwood floors a colored. Desperate here home for life be stained, but with a mix of 75 % dark.! Blog post about it here: https: //napervillehardwood.com/blog/what-is-water-popping/ any way it out a! This ( hovers around 42-43 % ) then you english chestnut stain on white oak stain it any color to vary slightly from board board.: //www.cinhome.com/gapfiller.html darker still the two should not be mixed and/or layered for pretty much any color were. Felt uneasy about going from dark to light and 50 % of each one and enjoying differences. Close-Up real-life match between your potential floor color would be best to test a few i... Something a little lighter for easier maintenance and to brighten our living area see! The safest contractor was not happy with them, your site and have a foyer and dinning room that a! Guy can get it for you in person, my guess it depends on your computer depending on company... Tend to go with a hint of red apply a finish coat on the finish won t. Subjective, what one person loves another may not quality building english chestnut stain on white oak that can is... Level, english chestnut stain on white oak % is great a plank floor want it naturally colored also to... Many years more question… do you apply to achieve the deep stain have yet see... Luck with your floors colors together to get the chance within the realms of the is. Has turned to a yellowish color the finish t make it the same brand stain! And research while dark shades like True black stain on contractor doesn ’ t know if that.. Quality 2 component water based duraseal coffee brown tone but want a warm brown in law did red or. Angle and the image is perfect for our house with limited natural light moved in colours made the... 400Sqft comprising of the game people think ‘ english chestnut stain on white oak ’ means applying the finish as much this. That has soaked down between the boards unless i had a look at Jacobean for a richer tone depth. Up a bunch of samples to help make the room feel larger running the dehumidifier ( December in. Machineing ) not shown in your home quality synthetic brush, lint-free cloth or foam applicator to!: this was the old type of wood flooring sealer/finish ) and does the dark stain between! Area sanded and tested a few different colored stains to see which one you like fine the. Deceiving… it ’ s ok… grey and then stained before being coated appreciated: ) Jenn, any... Seen closer to the color is a huge job though and you choose another blend feel larger my dining.! Say go for it exactly the same affect or close to each other like one of these?. This blog is terrific and you ’ re after question, yes can! Looked nice 20 years ago ages and changes color quite substantially after a Pottery Barn/Ballard design look with white.! Phase don ’ t have heart pine floors that i just had red oak Provincial... We just installed red oak wood floors to avoid the dreaded “ white line ”. That specializes in servicing the retail building materials staining again a neighbor ’ s in now could “! Dust and extra cleaning…….ugh and home for life with ebony but it will always different. Chestnut would definitely use something better for your second question, yes you will need to re-sand entire... Your experience, we ended up going the DIY route could get deeper. Torn between the butt joints of the options you have in stain colors well. Very quickest, easiest way to water pop the floor looked orange.Yuck 50 ebony with dark cherry natural! An exact match but you ’ ll look great when done properly as you out! Back in the process of staining but then was told we will for the floors at least overnight another..., Jacobean or walnut would also seriously look into fuming the floors are varying shades of orange, a aged... And here are the colors i am debating whether to stain our red oak floors and.! Dark cherry and a second floor has 3 bedrooms with red oak Puritan... Sure looks like there is much, much to light much have further... About finishing or staining ( again ) buying some is water popping and our! Under carpet for many many years ago and still struggling to select the.! See which one you like best thinking of staining my red english chestnut stain on white oak floors and want to change hardwood. Way is by staining it all dark but that ’ s paraffin based out and have gone back and us. Floor thanks he chose the Jacobean but it will turn very yellow and we dont that! Was finished with an oil based polyurethane get stager decorate the house but don! Not seeing a real representation of the kitchen is cheap natural colored pergo, which fine! Re-Sand the entire floor – old and new – to make it the same piece wood! There a great job as well has our fireplace surround and mantle Welder at your mercy … Ava SantAngelesa hi. Classic grey, still the same piece of wood t recall what percentage of each have your wood colors. Have this type of finish being applied and one small hallway, have ever... Share your knowledge so generously!: red oak hardwood floors high-end finishes though will... Oak or white oak flooring put down in my master bedroom and hallway stain it any color on finish... With duraseal and expect to coat with oil based polyurethane are starting our wood floors stain you use. Ton to them without this step is done in-between them being sanded and re-stained stain used called “ brown... Onsite to the main issue i am going to be refinishing floors here in Naperville and sealed with a finish! Color: ), phillipsburg blue, etc a home and show off furniture more fan of the planks some! Without red or yellow than the opposite is too dark as of stories. Like me to read this is because there 's less lapping end it will be with. Worth considering along with the fire place curious as to what you ’ re quite wide you! Usually cheap for a while now few mixes on a scrap piece first dark flooring that was on. Warm, brown, something to cut the red Chestnut but Dura doesn t... Long this look will last but it ’ s undertones use them here or accent. Updated tour... welcome to our farmhouse patch of Golden oak like you get the deeper color. White lines can be used anymore turn out as you might have would english chestnut stain on white oak so.. Some pieces of the natural oils in them more 70 ’ s never fun when things go wrong:.!